Maus Law Firm

No Recovery

Call For a Free Consultation

(855) 999-5297

Million dollar advocates forum

When Does a Car Accident Go to Court?

When Does a Car Accident Go to Court?

Car accidents are stressful events, and the aftermath can often be just as challenging, especially when it comes to legal matters. While most car accident cases are resolved through insurance settlements, there are instances where the complexities of a case necessitate taking it to court. This article aims to highlight the specific conditions under which a car accident claim might move from negotiation tables to a courtroom. Understanding these scenarios can help those involved in such accidents make informed decisions about their legal options.

If you are someone who is dealing with car accident claims and is worried about the legal complexities, then don’t worry anymore. Reach out to Maus Law Firm for the justice and compensation you deserve.

Moving on, let’s find out:

Reasons for Going to Court

Not all car accident disputes can be settled through insurance negotiations. When certain conditions are present, taking the matter to court may be the only viable option to seek justice and fair compensation.

Ongoing Disputes

One of the primary reasons for a car accident case going to court is ongoing disputes between the involved parties. Disagreements can arise over who was at fault, the extent of the damages, or the compensation due. If these disputes cannot be resolved through mediation or negotiation, the court becomes the next step for resolution. This often involves presenting evidence such as eyewitness testimony, traffic camera footage, and accident reconstruction reports to a judge or jury.

Inadequate Settlement Offers

Sometimes, despite attempts at negotiation, the parties cannot reach a settlement agreement. If the insurance company’s settlement offer does not adequately cover all damages, including medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering, the injured party may choose to reject the offer and take the matter to court in hopes of receiving a more appropriate compensation.

Insurance Company Non-Responsiveness

Another scenario that might necessitate court action is when an insurance company fails to respond adequately to a demand letter. If the insurer does not engage in meaningful communication or negotiations, the injured party may have no choice but to file a lawsuit to get the attention and response they deserve.

Serious Injuries and Significant Damages

Cases involving serious injuries and significant damages often end up in court. Insurance companies may be reluctant to offer fair settlements that reflect the gravity of the injuries and the financial impact on the victim. In such situations, a court trial may be necessary to ensure that the victim receives just compensation.

Uninsured Drivers

Dealing with uninsured drivers adds another layer of complexity to car accident claims. If the at-fault driver does not have insurance, the victim may need to pursue legal action to obtain compensation directly from the driver.

Disputed Traffic Tickets

Sometimes, the outcome of traffic tickets related to the accident can influence the decision to go to court. If there is a dispute over the tickets issued, a court hearing may be required to determine liability, which can affect the overall claim.

Steps to File a Car Accident Case

The journey from a car accident to a courtroom can be intricate. Here’s a breakdown of the steps involved in filing a car accident case, guiding you through the legal maze.

Step1: Consult with an Attorney

The first step after deciding to take legal action is to consult with a personal injury attorney. An attorney’s expertise is invaluable in navigating the complexities of the law and ensuring that you receive the compensation you deserve. During the initial consultation, be prepared to provide a comprehensive account of the accident and any related documentation.

Step2: Filing a Formal Legal Complaint

The next step is for your attorney to file a formal legal complaint. This document is crucial as it sets the stage for your case, outlining the parties involved, the jurisdiction, and the specific claims and facts of the case. It also formally demands judgment or relief.

Step3: Serving the Defendants

After the complaint is filed, it must be served to the defendants, which typically includes the at-fault driver and their insurance company. This process ensures that the defendants are officially notified of the lawsuit and have the opportunity to respond.

Step4: Discovery Phase

The discovery phase is where both parties exchange detailed information related to the case. This phase is critical as it allows both sides to gather the evidence necessary to support their claims or defenses.

Step5: Trial Preparation

In preparation for trial, your attorney will continue to build your case, gathering evidence, and strategizing the best approach to present in court. This preparation is key to a successful outcome.

Contact Maus Law Firm for Car Accident Settlements 

When facing the prospect of a car accident case going to court, it’s essential to have the right legal team on your side. With years of experience in personal injury law, Maus Law Firm has the knowledge to navigate complex legal challenges. We prioritize our clients, offering personalized service and attention to detail. We are available 24/7 so that you’re never alone in your legal journey.

Reach out for a free consultation and take the first step towards securing the compensation you deserve.

FAQs – When Does a Car Accident Go to Court 

How Long After a Car Accident Can You Sue in Florida? 

In Florida, the statute of limitations for filing a personal injury lawsuit after a car accident is generally four years from the date of the accident. However, if the accident resulted in a death, a wrongful death lawsuit must be filed within two years from the date of death.

Do You Get Excess Back if Not Your Fault? 

If an accident was not your fault, you may have to pay the excess initially. However, if it’s proven that the other driver was at fault and your insurer can recover the costs from their insurer, your excess should be refunded.

What is the Average Settlement for a Car Accident in Florida? 

The average settlement for a car accident in Florida varies widely. For minor injuries, settlements can range from $5,743 to $1,601,517 for severe injuries. The exact amount depends on the specifics of the case, including injury severity and incurred losses.

What Happens if You Don’t Admit Fault? 

If you don’t admit fault in a car accident, insurance adjusters will investigate the accident to determine fault based on evidence and state laws. Not admitting fault can be important as it may affect your ability to recover compensation.

What Happens if a Driver Does Not Admit Fault? 

When a driver does not admit fault, the insurance companies involved will conduct an investigation to determine who is at fault. The outcome of this investigation will influence how claims are paid out.

What is a Non-Fault Accident? 

A non-fault accident is one where you are not responsible for the accident. In such cases, you can claim compensation against the at-fault driver through their insurance company. Your own insurer may cover your damages initially and then seek reimbursement from the at-fault party’s insurer6.


Client Testimonial

"Even when I was not able to get a physician to follow up with me for a broken bone following a car accident, the Maus firm, in particular Rocio, worked hard on my behalf and reached a good settlement for me. This was accomplished long distance, as the accident happened in Florida and I live in Indiana. They worked on my case for 3 years and did not give up."

Posted By: Debra Murray

Contact us today to learn about your legal options

Super Lawyers badge Million dollar advocates badge Super Lawyers badge Florida legal elite badge avvo badge

If you or a loved one has been seriously injured in an accident, you deserve an attorney you can trust

– to prepare your case properly, and to obtain the compensation you deserve. The Attorneys at the Maus Law Firm have tried more than 130 jury trials, and recovered millions of dollars on behalf of their clients. In fact, most of our cases are referred from our former clients on cases in which we served as the lead accident claims lawyer.

The Maus Law Firm

Toll Free: 855-999-5297

Local: 954-784-6310

Local: 954-833-1413


205 West Davie Blvd,
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33315

Get Directions

Proudly Serving Clients in Ft. Lauderdale, Boca Raton, Hollywood, Pompano Beach, Davie, Oakland Park, and all of South Florida

© 2024 Maus Law Firm, All rights reserved.

Schedule a Free & Confidential Consultation


    No Fee
    Until We Win

    Call Us